view raw text
GUINEAS WINNERS FAIL IN DERBY The defeat of The Panther in the Epsom Derby after a startling victory in the Two Thousand Guineas is not a novelty in the book over the two classics classicsIt It may be of some interest to recall the occasions on which the winner of the Guineas has been beaten iu the Derby by an animal that he defeated in the firstnamed race It has occurred on thirteen occa ¬ sions in the past fiftyeight years as follows follows18G1 18G1 Diophantus won the Guineas Kettledrum being second Kettledrum won the Derby and Dio ¬ phantus was third 1870 MacGrcgor won the Guineas Kingcraft be ¬ ing second Kingcraft won the Derby and Mac Gregor was fourth 1872 Prince Charlie won the Guineas Cremorne being second Cromorne won the Derby and Prince Charlie was seventh 1873 Gang Forward won the Guineas Doiicaster being fifth Doiicaster won the Derby and Gang Forward was second 1877 Chamant won the Guineas Silvio being third Silvio won the Derby and Chamant was tenth tenth1SU1 1SU1 Peregrine won the Guineas Iroquols being second Iruquois won the Derby and Peregrine was second second1S83 1S83 Galliard won the Guineas St Blnise being fourth St Blalse won the Derby and Galliard was third third1SSD 1SSD Enthusiast won the Guineas Donovan being second Donovan won the Derby and Enthusiast was eighth eighth1S92 1S92 Bonavista won the Guineas Sir Hugo being sixth Sir Hugo won the Derby and Bonavista was unplaced 1895 Kirkconnel won the Guineas Sir Visto be ¬ ing third Sir Visto won the Derby and Kirkconnel was third third189S 189S Disraeli won the Guineas Jeddah being fifth Jeddah won the Derby and Disraeli was tenth 1902 Sceptre won the Guineas Ard Patrick being third Ard Patrick won the Derby and Sceptre was fourth 1910 Neil Gow won the Guineas Lemberg being second Lemberg won the Derby and Neil Gow was fourth
